Advanced level

Equations, inequalities and systems with a parameter

A parameter is not a second unknown but a setting — one letter that turns a single problem into a whole family of them. The linear equation and its degenerate case, the discriminant as a condition on the number of roots, Vieta’s formulas, an inequality that holds for every x, and a line meeting a parabola.

Before you start

This topic builds on earlier ideas. Before you start, it's worth working through the lessons below — they'll make everything click:

Where this is used

Real situations where you count exactly the way this lesson teaches:

  • A phone tariff and the price per minute
    Tariff A costs 30 a month plus m per minute, tariff B costs 50 plus 0.10 per minute. Equal cost means 30 + mt = 50 + 0.1t, that is (m − 0.1)t = 20. At m = 0.10 the coefficient of t vanishes and the equation has no solution: the tariffs differ by a flat 20 whatever the usage. At m = 0.15 they meet at t = 400 minutes.
  • A bulk discount and the break-even rate
    A shop sells an item at 40 and offers r percent off on an order of 12. The condition "12 with the discount cheaper than 10 without it" is 480(1 − r/100) < 400, so r > 16.7%. A 15% discount is not enough, 20% is — and the threshold sits exactly where the inequality flips.
  • Manufacturing and the break-even price
    A run of 500 units costs 5,000 in fixed cost plus 12 per unit. The profit at price c is 500(c − 12) − 5,000 and is zero at c = 22. The price is the parameter that sets the whole run: every unit of price above 22 is 500 of profit, every one below it is 500 of loss.
  • Control engineering and a controller gain
    A simple control loop has the characteristic equation s² + 4s + k = 0, where k is the gain setting. The discriminant is 16 − 4k, so for k < 4 the loop settles without overshoot and for k > 4 it starts to oscillate. The setting k = 4 is the boundary — and that is the number an engineer types into the controller.

All formulas

  • Linear equation with a parameter

    ax=b: a0    x=ba; a=0,b0    ; a=b=0    xRax = b: \ a \neq 0 \implies x = \tfrac{b}{a}; \ a = 0, b \neq 0 \implies \varnothing; \ a = b = 0 \implies x \in \mathbb{R}

    three cases, settled by the coefficient of the unknown

  • Degree condition

    ax2+bx+c=0 is quadratic    a0ax^2 + bx + c = 0 \ \text{is quadratic} \iff a \neq 0

    the first question in every parameter problem with an x² in it

  • Discriminant and the number of roots

    Δ>0    two roots,Δ=0    one,Δ<0    none\Delta > 0 \implies \text{two roots}, \quad \Delta = 0 \implies \text{one}, \quad \Delta < 0 \implies \text{none}

    the condition on the parameter comes out of an inequality on the discriminant

  • Vieta’s formulas

    x1+x2=ba,x1x2=cax_1 + x_2 = -\frac{b}{a}, \qquad x_1 \cdot x_2 = \frac{c}{a}

    a condition on the roots without computing the roots

  • An always-true inequality

    ax2+bx+c>0 for every x    a>0 and Δ<0ax^2 + bx + c > 0 \ \text{for every } x \iff a > 0 \ \text{and} \ \Delta < 0

    both conditions at once — the discriminant alone is not enough

The equation (m3)x=5(m - 3)x = 5 has two letters, but they do not play the same part. We solve for xx — that is the unknown. The letter mm is a parameter: a number given from outside, set by someone before the arithmetic starts. One setting, one equation; a different setting, a different equation.

That is why a parameter problem almost never asks "what is xx". It asks: for which values of the parameter does the equation have one solution, two, or none; for which is the inequality always true; for which does the line touch the parabola. The answer is a set — and that set lives on the parameter axis, not on the xx axis.

The linear equation: three cases

ax=b:a0    x=ba;a=0,b0    ;a=b=0    xRax = b: \quad a \neq 0 \implies x = \tfrac{b}{a}; \quad a = 0, b \neq 0 \implies \varnothing; \quad a = b = 0 \implies x \in \mathbb{R}

Everything is settled by the coefficient of the unknown. As long as it is not zero, divide and there is one solution. When it is zero, the unknown disappears from the equation and a statement about numbers alone is left — either true or false.

For which m does the equation (m − 3)x = 5 have no solutions?

The same mechanism works one degree up. In (m2)x2+3x+1=0(m - 2)x^2 + 3x + 1 = 0 the value m=2m = 2 takes the second degree away — what is left is 3x+1=03x + 1 = 0, a linear equation with one solution. Which is why the first question in any parameter problem with an x2x^2 in it is:

ax2+bx+c=0 is quadratic    a0ax^2 + bx + c = 0 \ \text{is quadratic} \iff a \neq 0

The discriminant decides the number of roots

For a0a \neq 0 the number of roots depends on nothing but the sign of the discriminant:

Δ>0    two roots,Δ=0    one,Δ<0    none\Delta > 0 \implies \text{two roots}, \qquad \Delta = 0 \implies \text{one}, \qquad \Delta < 0 \implies \text{none}

A condition imposed on the roots therefore becomes an inequality in the parameter, solved with the methods of the lesson on quadratic and rational inequalities.

For which m does x² + mx + 9 = 0 have exactly one solution?

Vieta’s formulas: conditions on roots you never compute

x1+x2=ba,x1x2=cax_1 + x_2 = -\frac{b}{a}, \qquad x_1 \cdot x_2 = \frac{c}{a}

When a problem imposes a condition on the sum or the product of the roots, computing them with the discriminant is the long way round. Vieta’s formulas hand you both quantities straight from the coefficients.

One proviso is compulsory: first make sure the roots exist at all, by adding the condition Δ0\Delta \ge 0. Without it you can easily quote a value of the parameter for which the sum of the roots is exactly what was asked — except that there are no roots.

An inequality satisfied for every x

ax2+bx+c>0 for every x    a>0 and Δ<0ax^2 + bx + c > 0 \ \text{for every } x \iff a > 0 \ \text{and} \ \Delta < 0

Both conditions have to hold at once: the parabola opens upwards and it never meets the axis. A negative discriminant alone is not enough — with a<0a < 0 the same parabola would lie entirely below the axis.

For which m is x² + mx + 4 > 0 satisfied by every real number?
−6−4−20246m ∈ (−4, 4)
The solution set of a parameter problem is drawn on the parameter axis m, not on the x axis — that is the axis the answer lives on.

Systems with a parameter

A system of two linear equations with a parameter is settled exactly like a single equation: eliminate one unknown and a linear equation is left, with the same three cases. One solution means the lines cross, no solutions means they are parallel, infinitely many means they coincide.

More interesting is a system of a line and a parabola. Substitution turns it into a single quadratic equation, and the discriminant of that equation says how many points the two curves share:

−2−101234−4−20246810y = x²m = 1 — two pointsm = −1 — tangentm = −3 — no points
Three lines from the family y = 2x + m. Only the setting m changes, and the number of points shared with the parabola drops from two to none.
For which m is the line y = 2x + m tangent to the parabola y = x²?

Practice

Work through a set of exercises — they get harder as you go. At the end you'll see your score and the mistakes worth reviewing.

Exercise 1 of 8Score: 0
The m that makes a root of 3: x² + mx + 6 = 0

Common mistakes

  • Treating the parameter as an unknown — the answer is a set of values of mm, not a value of xx. It pays to reread the question at the end.
  • Dividing by a coefficient containing the parameter — from (m3)x=5(m - 3)x = 5 you may not jump to x=5m3x = \tfrac{5}{m-3}: at m=3m = 3 that divides by zero. The zero case is always handled separately.
  • Skipping the condition a0a \neq 0 — in (m2)x2+3x+1=0(m - 2)x^2 + 3x + 1 = 0 the value m=2m = 2 gives a linear equation, for which a discriminant means nothing.
  • Vieta’s formulas without checking the discriminant — a condition on the sum or product of the roots only makes sense while Δ0\Delta \ge 0.
  • One condition instead of two for "for every xx" — you need a>0a > 0 and Δ<0\Delta < 0; the discriminant alone settles nothing.
  • Closing the ends at Δ=0\Delta = 0 — for a strict inequality the value of the parameter giving Δ=0\Delta = 0 does not belong to the answer, because the parabola touches the axis there.

Formula card

Topic: Equations, inequalities and systems with a parameter

  • Linear equation with a parameter

    ax=b: a0    x=ba; a=0,b0    ; a=b=0    xRax = b: \ a \neq 0 \implies x = \tfrac{b}{a}; \ a = 0, b \neq 0 \implies \varnothing; \ a = b = 0 \implies x \in \mathbb{R}

    three cases, settled by the coefficient of the unknown

  • Degree condition

    ax2+bx+c=0 is quadratic    a0ax^2 + bx + c = 0 \ \text{is quadratic} \iff a \neq 0

    the first question in every parameter problem with an x² in it

  • Discriminant and the number of roots

    Δ>0    two roots,Δ=0    one,Δ<0    none\Delta > 0 \implies \text{two roots}, \quad \Delta = 0 \implies \text{one}, \quad \Delta < 0 \implies \text{none}

    the condition on the parameter comes out of an inequality on the discriminant

  • Vieta’s formulas

    x1+x2=ba,x1x2=cax_1 + x_2 = -\frac{b}{a}, \qquad x_1 \cdot x_2 = \frac{c}{a}

    a condition on the roots without computing the roots

  • An always-true inequality

    ax2+bx+c>0 for every x    a>0 and Δ<0ax^2 + bx + c > 0 \ \text{for every } x \iff a > 0 \ \text{and} \ \Delta < 0

    both conditions at once — the discriminant alone is not enough

−2−101234−4−20246810y = x²m = 1 — two pointsm = −1 — tangentm = −3 — no points
The parabola y = x² and three lines y = 2x + m. The discriminant decides whether the line cuts the parabola twice, touches it, or misses it.
−6−4−20246m ∈ (−4, 4)
The answer to a parameter problem is a set of values of m. For x² + mx + 4 > 0 to hold for every x, that set is the interval (−4, 4).

Frequently asked questions

Related articles